Buying a Home in Forest Hills, Queens NY: A Neighborhood Guide for Buyers

Stone Tudor Church in the Gardens in Forest Hills Gardens, Queens, with a red tile roof under a blue sky

Forest Hills is the Queens neighborhood buyers describe as a suburb in the city. Tree-lined streets, Tudor-style homes, a walkable shopping district, and an express subway to Manhattan have made it one of the most desirable places to buy in Queens NY real estate. This guide covers the housing stock, the prices, the commute, and what buyers should know before making an offer.

What Makes Forest Hills Different

Forest Hills sits in central Queens, between Rego Park, Kew Gardens, and Flushing Meadows–Corona Park, with Forest Park along its southern edge. At its heart is Forest Hills Gardens, a planned community founded in 1909 on about 142 acres and designed by architect Grosvenor Atterbury with landscaping by Frederick Law Olmsted Jr. — a private enclave of curving streets, Tudor-style homes, and small resident parks.

Around the Gardens, grand pre-war co-op buildings line Queens Boulevard, with post-war towers and blocks of single-family homes to the north. Austin Street, between Yellowstone Boulevard and Ascan Avenue, is the neighborhood’s main shopping and dining strip.

What You Can Buy in Forest Hills

Forest Hills is a co-op-dominant market, with far more co-op apartments than single-family homes. The large pre-war elevator buildings along Queens Boulevard are the value story for many buyers: spacious layouts, solid construction, and strong financials. Condominiums exist but are less common.

At the top of the market, detached Tudor, Colonial Revival, and Mediterranean homes inside Forest Hills Gardens trade at a premium. Outside the Gardens, single-family homes on quiet residential blocks offer a more suburban feel, and newer condominiums along Austin Street add a modern option.

Because the market is co-op-heavy, most Forest Hills buyers should expect board approval, a financial review, and often a higher down payment. Our guide to co-op board approval in Queens explains the process, and our co-op vs. condo comparison can help you choose the right ownership type.

Forest Hills Home Prices

Prices in Forest Hills run toward the higher end of the Queens market, and the mix of property types matters more than any single median. According to Realtor.com’s October 2026 data for Forest Hills, the median listing price was $397,750 and the median sold price was $485,000, with homes selling for about 99% of asking price. PropertyShark reported a median sale price of $437,500 in the third quarter of 2026, up 10.5% year over year.

The spread behind those medians is wide: co-op apartments are the most attainable entry point, while single-family houses — especially inside Forest Hills Gardens — commonly sell for well over $1 million. Buyers should also keep the city’s mansion tax in mind: purchases at $1 million and above trigger New York City’s tiered mansion tax, which applies to a meaningful share of Forest Hills purchases. Ask your attorney how transfer taxes affect your closing costs before you set your budget.

Getting Around: Transit and Daily Life

Transit is one of Forest Hills’ strongest selling points. The 71st Avenue station serves the E, F, M, and R trains, with express service to Midtown Manhattan in about 20 to 25 minutes, and the Forest Hills LIRR station at Station Square adds another fast option into Manhattan.

Daily life centers on Austin Street’s restaurants, cafes, boutiques, and grocery stores, with more shopping along Queens Boulevard and Metropolitan Avenue. Forest Hills Stadium — the former home of the U.S. Open until 1977, now a concert venue — anchors the neighborhood’s cultural life, and Forest Park, one of the city’s largest parks, sits just to the south.

What Buyers Should Know Before Making an Offer

A few practical points can save Forest Hills buyers time and surprises. First, if you are buying in Forest Hills Gardens, understand that the private association owns the streets and enforces its own rules and fees — review those obligations with your attorney before signing a contract. Second, check a property’s tax and sales history through NYC’s ACRIS system before making an offer.

Third, visit at different times of day: the blocks along Austin Street and Queens Boulevard are busy and commercial, while the interior residential streets are quiet. And if you are comparing neighborhoods, our guide to buying a home in Astoria shows how another popular Queens neighborhood stacks up.

Forest Hills rewards buyers who do their homework: know whether you want a co-op or a house, get your financing and board package ready early, and lean on a local agent who knows the buildings and the blocks. For the right buyer, it still offers one of the best combinations of space, transit, and community in Queens.

Lea esta guía en español: Comprar una casa en Forest Hills, Queens NY: guía para compradores

Thinking about buying a home in Forest Hills or anywhere in Queens? Call Empire Fine Homes at 917.554.0546 — we live and work in Queens, and we would be glad to help you find the right home.

🏡 Never Miss a New Queens Listing

Get new listings & weekly open houses in your inbox — free, every week.

JOIN THE FREE LIST

Skip to content